Site Navigation

Home
About
Services
Testimonials
Contact
News
Info
FAQ

Sweet Goodness Cake Co

"A Specialty Cake Shoppe in Coppes Commons"

About Us

Welcome to Sweet Goodness Cake Company, where we specialize in creating custom cakes for all occasions! Located in Nappanee, IN, our Mongolian-inspired bakery offers a wide selection of delicious treats made with love and care. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, wedding, or any special event, our cakes serve as the perfect centerpiece. Experience the sweet goodness that has become a cherished part of our community.

Our Story

Welcome to Sweet Goodness Cake Company, your go-to specialty cake shoppe nestled inside Coppes Commons in Nappanee, IN—where every bite tells a story and every celebration becomes a little sweeter. What started over 10 years ago with a single cake pop at a family Christmas celebration has blossomed into a beloved local bakery known for its creativity, quality, and irresistible treats. Inspired by a tray of snowman-shaped cake pops brought by an aunt, our journey began with curiosity, a few not-so-perfect attempts, and a whole lot of determination. Through trial and error, that simple idea turned into a passion—and today, we proudly serve up handcrafted desserts made from scratch with love.

At Sweet Goodness Cake Company, we specialize in custom cakes designed to be the centerpiece of your most meaningful moments. Whether you’re planning a wedding, birthday, anniversary, or special event, our custom wedding cakes and celebration cakes are thoughtfully created to reflect your vision and style. From elegant tiered masterpieces to fun, themed creations, every cake is baked fresh and decorated with care to ensure both beauty and flavor shine through.

Our menu extends far beyond cakes, offering a wide variety of custom desserts to satisfy every craving. Indulge in our delicate custom macarons, rich and creamy cheesecakes, soft and flavorful cupcakes, and beautifully decorated cookies. Of course, we still honor where it all began with our signature custom cake pops—perfectly bite-sized, deliciously moist, and endlessly customizable. Seasonal favorites like pumpkin pie, pecan pie, and Dutch apple pie add a comforting, homemade touch to any gathering.

Looking for something refreshing to pair with your treat? We also serve fresh lemonade, Italian sodas, and smooth cold brew coffee, making Sweet Goodness Cake Company the perfect stop for a midday pick-me-up or a sweet afternoon escape.

What truly sets us apart is our commitment to custom orders and personalized service. Every item we create is made from scratch and tailored to your needs, ensuring your desserts are as unique as your celebration. Be sure to ask about our pre-order specials to secure your favorites for upcoming events.

Beyond the shop, our mobile bakery and event trailer bring the Sweet Goodness experience directly to you. Perfect for weddings, parties, festivals, and corporate events, our mobile setup allows guests to enjoy fresh, handcrafted desserts on-site—adding a fun and memorable touch to any occasion.

We also love connecting with our community through interactive experiences like our popular gingerbread decorating classes, where creativity and sweetness come together for all ages to enjoy.

At Sweet Goodness Cake Company, we believe dessert should be joyful, memorable, and made with heart. Stop by our shop in Coppes Commons or book us for your next event—and discover why our sweet creations have become a cherished part of the Nappanee community.

Areas Served

Nappanee, IN | Elkhart County, IN | Kosciusko County, IN | Marshall County, IN | LaGrange County, IN | Noble County, IN | Fulton County, IN | Saint Joseph, IN

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

Our Services include:

Our Products include:

Testimonials

On 3/7/2026 Liz Heinke had this to say:
Called lots of bakeries, this one just knew exactly what to ask and was very professional. We had chocolate and red velvet layers with strawberry filling. The whole party loved the cake flavors. They did a wonderful job on the decoration! It was better than the inspo pic we gave them! ❤️ 💙 💜

On 2/26/2026 Tiffany Graber had this to say:
Most cheesecakes with fruit fillings are overly sweet. Sweet Goodness has figured out the perfect ratio. We tried their white chocolate raspberry cheesecake and their strawberry cheesecake today. Both cheesecakes were perfectly balanced. From previous experience their macarons and cupcakes are on point as well. They don’t have seating, but definitely worth a stop if you want a quality sweet treat that won’t disappoint.

On 1/6/2026 Jolena Borntrager had this to say:
Great cupcakes and macarons! My go-to for anything cake related.

On 1/3/2026 Alexsis Bistodeau had this to say:
Did a AMAZING job on our wedding cake. The baker was a very sweet woman and was very kind during the process and open to communication

On 11/10/2025 Miriam had this to say:
Some of the best cheesecake I have ever had. Marlene's shop is absolutely adorable and her items are amazing, fresh quality!

Contact Us

Sweet Goodness Cake Co
401 E Market St Nappanee, IN 46550
Phone: (574) 354-4544
Email: marlene@sweetgoodnesscakeco.com

Located in Coppes Commons

Where To Find Us

Follow us on Facebook
Follow us on Instagram

Payment Types Accepted

American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Debit Cards, Discover, MasterCard, Visa, Venmo

Our Hours

Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.

Monday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM - 4:00 PM

News

🎄🎂 Sweeten Your Holiday Season with Sweet Goodness Cake Co. 🎂🎄

'Tis the season for festive flavors and joyful gatherings! Let Sweet Goodness Cake Co. make your celebrations a little sweeter with our specially crafted holiday treats. From traditional Yule logs to custom-designed cakes and cookies, our holiday menu is designed to delight! Place your orders early to ensure you have the perfect dessert centerpiece to share with family and friends.

📍 Visit us at: 401 E Market St, Nappanee, IN 46550 📞 Order now: (574) 354-4544 ✨ Be prepared to indulge in scrumptiousness that makes your holidays memorable! #HolidaySweets #CustomCakes #SweetGoodnessCakeCo

Cake and Cupcakes: Bourbon Caramel Spice
Cheesecake: Butterscotch with toasted Meringue
Latte: Harvest Spiced Tea Latte

Info

Offerings

FAQ

Do you do wedding cake tastings?
Yes we do! Please call or email us through the "Contact" tab to find a date for your tasting.
Do you have gluten and dairy free offerings?
Our macaroons are crafted to be entirely gluten-free. However, please be aware that our other culinary creations do contain gluten and dairy ingredients.
Do you have a brick and mortar location?
Yes we do! We are located in the upstairs of Coppes Commons.
Can we book the mobile bakery for private events?
Yes you can! Our mobiel bakery is perfect for weddings, business meetings, birthdays, graduations, reunions, church events, and more! Call or email us through the "Contact" tab today to tell us about the type, location, and time of event and we will get back to you with availability and a menu plan!

Legal

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy